Thirteenth Court of Appeals

Case: 13-23-00491-CV    
13-23-00491-CV
11/14/2023
Oil & Gas
Norman Ross Becken, et al. 
1893 Oil & Gas, Ltd. and ELP2 Minerals, LLC 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
West Publishing 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
09/04/2024Additional authorities filedAppellee
07/18/2024Reply brief filedAppellant
06/28/2024Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
04/15/2024Amended brief receivedAppellant
04/15/2024Amended brief filedAppellant
04/10/2024Brief received - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
06/25/2026Mandate issued 
06/12/2026Notice received 
05/01/2026Petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtMotion or Writ Denied
01/02/2026Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
11/18/2025Motion for extension of time to file petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtGrant motion
11/18/2025Motion for extension of time to file petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
10/09/2025Memorandum opinion issuedAffirmed
10/09/2025Retention time case file will be retained 
10/22/2024Submitted 
10/21/2024Letter filed 
10/21/2024Fee paid 
10/21/2024Oral argument exhibits filed 
10/15/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
10/01/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
09/30/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
09/24/2024Set for submission on oral argument 
09/05/2024Submission cancelled 
09/04/2024Additional authorities filed 
07/31/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
07/31/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
07/31/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
07/31/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
07/30/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
07/30/2024Set for submission on oral argument 
07/18/2024Reply brief filed 
07/10/2024Motion disposedGrant motion
07/01/2024Fee paid 
07/01/2024Motion filed 
06/28/2024Brief filed - oral argument requested 
06/07/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
05/31/2024Fee paid 
05/31/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
05/21/2024Email received 
05/15/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
05/14/2024Fee paid 
05/14/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
04/18/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
04/15/2024Case ready to be set 
04/15/2024Amended brief filed 
04/15/2024Amended brief received 
04/10/2024Brief received - oral argument requested 
03/28/2024Fee paid 
03/28/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
03/14/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
02/29/2024Fee paid 
02/29/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
01/30/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
01/26/2024Fee paid 
01/26/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
01/12/2024Additional copies of documents received after initial filing 
01/12/2024Appearance of counsel 
12/27/2023Exhibits filed 
12/27/2023Reporters record filed 
12/21/2023Corrected document requested 
12/21/2023Reporters record filed 
12/21/2023Reporters record filed 
12/21/2023Reporters record filed 
12/20/2023Extension of time to file reporters record disposedGrant motion
12/18/2023Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
12/18/2023Docketing statement filed 
12/14/2023Notice of late docketing statement 
12/12/2023Clerks record filed 
11/30/2023Docketing statement filed 
11/29/2023Fee paid 
11/14/2023Notice of appeal filed in court of appeals 
11/13/2023Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
10/17/2023Judgment signed by trial court judge 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
06/25/2026Case StoredCase stored
06/25/2032RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Arends, LauriAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Clair, Laurel DeannaAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Schwinghammer, ThomasAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Arey, ArnetteAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Furlong, KathrynAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Slayton, Karin KarlsonAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Kammerling, JessAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Clair, Bryan F.AppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Frost, MargaretAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Von Esch, KarlaAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Taubman, EricAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Grams, RobertAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Fitzgerald, ReginaAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Stulken, HaileyAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Moothart, MarilynAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Bacon, Jr., James EvansAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Kiekow, Gerald PaulAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Schnack, Michael CliffordAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Brown, Robert ReedAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Dawson, SherylAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Walker, DallasAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Broden, RogerAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Harris, RichardAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Raymond, GloriaAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Sickinger, CynthiaAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Fitzgerald, Barbara R.AppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Sandeen, DanAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Grande, ClarenceAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Theirault, DeborahAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Howlin, PattyAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Harriman, BartAppellant 
Jaeb, Charles G.Appellant 
Burnotte, CarolAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Forsythe, DanAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hodgson, ScottAppellant 
Anderson, CharlesAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hickman, Patricia A.AppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Christlieb, Isaac C.AppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Grams, LindaAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Lamp, JudyAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
1893 Oil & Gas, LtdAppelleeHon. Charles W. Gordon IV
Hon. Jessica Henry
Hon. Fred R. Jones
Hon. Mary Byars
Hon. Richard G. Foster
Hon. Jane M.N. Webre
Tice, Jennifer AnselmentAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hickman, Margaret MaryAppellant 
Bolling, DavidAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Olson, BarbaraAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Matz, RyanAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Grams, GeorgeAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
McKinley, AleneAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Kutz, Brian P.AppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Brickner, RussellAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Walker, BreannaAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Ruzynkski, Dawn MoellmanAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Stulken, KeithAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Gunderson, MichelleAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Becken, PeterAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Gustafson, GlennAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Klug, James ArthurAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Prickett, JillAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Bender, RuthAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Thomas, Pamela MarieAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Crawford, RichardAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Peters, StevenAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Bunce, Michael LeeAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Ferguson, Ruth AnnAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Gilbertson, EleanorAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
St. George, BarbaraAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Mathiowetz, MaryAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Taubman, AaronAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Quirk, LaurenAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Carlson, Judy K.AppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Schultenover, KathyAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Yankura, DebbieAppellant 
Howlin, CharlesAppellant 
Donlin, DonAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Benson, DianeAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Kammerling, ThomasAppellant 
Jaeb, David G.Appellant 
Maenhoudt, Joleen K.Appellant 
Reineke, WayneAppellant 
Schwinghammer, EvelynAppellant 
Christensen, Linda ThorpAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Lagergren, Paul ToddAppellant 
Matz, TimAppellant 
Grande, NathanAppellant 
Bartsch, StevenAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Lucken, SaraAppellant 
Dorsey, RobertAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Bibeau, JoanAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hickman, MelissaAppellant 
Forsythe, David W.AppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Rolfing, SueAppellant 
Hickman, Lisa MarieAppellant 
Finkel, LauraAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Sandberg, DeniseAppellant 
Vinje-Pippert, Colleen LeighAppellant 
ELP2 Minerals, LLCAppelleeHon. Jessica Henry
Hon. Charles W. Gordon IV
Hon. Jane M.N. Webre
Hon. Richard G. Foster
Hon. Walter Batla
Hon. Mary Byars
Davies, RuthAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Blaedorn, James L.AppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Laubach, GretchenAppellant 
Lundstrom, DavidAppellant 
Walker, RonAppellant 
Page, JimAppellant 
Bolling, JeanAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Reineke, DaleAppellant 
Bartsch, ThomasAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Rogers, KellyAppellant 
Carruthers, Wynell MortimeyerAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Kutz, Sean MichaelAppellant 
Griepentrog, NancyAppellant 
Dibley, Daniel RayAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Douglas, EdAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Paterson, JoanAppellant 
Douglas, RichardAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Mallet, ArlyndAppellant 
Forsythe, DaleAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Kiehne, RuthAppellant 
Bacon, Joseph CharlesAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Theisen, PamelaAppellant 
Bressler, JonAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Lundstom, ShirleyAppellant 
Shrode, PaulAppellant 
Darling, DavidAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Brownfield, SallyAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Swanson, DennisAppellant 
Veenendaal, RogerAppellant 
Saufferer, ScottAppellant 
Broden, Irving C.AppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Niemann, DeniseAppellant 
Darling, JulieAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Kantorowicz, JonAppellant 
Neutz, Nicolette AnnAppellant 
Lockhart, HenryAppellant 
Behlendorf, RobertAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Wenger, MaryAppellant 
Eells, KevinAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Townsend, AngelaAppellant 
Bressler, DavidAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Griepentrog, SteveAppellant 
Medicus, Mary WiestAppellant 
Griepentrog, ScottAppellant 
Brickner, Marjorie LeeAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Stringer, Cindy BresslerAppellant 
Lilja, PatAppellant 
Knedel, Jeanette M.Appellant 
Fischbach, SarahAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Robbe, Stephen MarkAppellant 
Saul, SheriAppellant 
Stulken, TylerAppellant 
Stanford, JohnAppellant 
Herkenhoff, CaroleAppellant 
Bressler, HollyAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Bacon, Jennifer LynnAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
O'Rourke, JudyAppellant 
Broden, MarkAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Ncklous, Donna M.Appellant 
Hanson, LylaAppellant 
Wharton, MargaretAppellant 
Griepentrog, KayeAppellant 
Schultz, PattyAppellant 
Kennedy, LinneaAppellant 
Bunce, George M.AppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Loomis, Allison LynnAppellant 
Lagergren, Thomas RichardAppellant 
Sanchez Mason, Ruth AnnAppellant 
Krenz, JulieAppellant 
Anderson, Toby Le RoyAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Balch, LisaAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Frost, JamesAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Bolling, MaryAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Gerdeman, CollinAppellant 
Lane, Fayne ElizabethAppellant 
Hagen, Shayla PetersAppellant 
Carruthers, Marc AndrewAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Alton, BeckyAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Grams, MargueriteAppellant 
Govig, SarahAppellant 
Berg, JudyAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Johnson, WilliamAppellant 
Bolling, BrianAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Ahrendt, CherylAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Stender, MaryAppellant 
Anderson, Laverne E.AppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Goebel, ArthurAppellant 
Mickelson, ArloAppellant 
Lechner, ChristineAppellant 
Kantorowicz, JanaAppellant 
Powers, SharonAppellant 
Gurholt, YvonneAppellant 
Kutz, BrianAppellant 
Bartsch, JamesAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
L., ElaineAppellant 
Fredeen, KathleenAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Metz, HelenAppellant 
Furlong, PatrickAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Shrode, MarthaAppellant 
Estelle, LisaAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Forsythe, WilliamAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Sandberg, DebraAppellant 
Smeby, Joel H.Appellant 
Mahoney, KevinAppellant 
Levang, JoAnn M.Appellant 
West, Jr., Joseph BenjaminAppellant 
Dirk, JanisAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hruska, MariaAppellant 
Hauser, AmyAppellant 
Sams-Hernandez, TabithaAppellant 
Thompson, SonjaAppellant 
Holm, Stephen JohnAppellant 
Brickner, Russell W.AppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Loomis, Jr., Howard BurtonAppellant 
Johnson, PaulAppellant 
Jaskowiak, KarenAppellant 
Hazen, KristiAppellant 
Lundquist, DebbieAppellant 
Sandeen, JeanAppellant 
Brady, KaylaAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
McIntire, Rhonda AnnAppellant 
Benson, BarbaraAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Dueber, Patricia K.AppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Fitzgerald, David J.AppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Wiest, AnitaAppellant 
Smeby, MarkAppellant 
Fahnberg, CraigAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Moellman, JimAppellant 
Broden, ArvidAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Fahnberg, PatsyAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hodgson, StevenAppellant 
Loomer, SusanAppellant 
Todd Mason-Martin, Beth LouisAppellant 
Holm, DavidAppellant 
Johnson, SandraAppellant 
Jaeb, Adrian J.Appellant 
Kormer, JeanAppellant 
Zimara, MargotAppellant 
Donlin, DanielAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Olson, BarbaraAppellant 
Dibley, Joseph DeanAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Quirk, JamesAppellant 
Doyle, KarenAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Ness, SteveAppellant 
Caswell, BruceAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Bolling, RoyAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hallberg, MyrnaAppellant 
Wiest, PerryAppellant 
Bacon, Dorothy MayAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Mickelson, DeanAppellant 
Luckemeyer, Kurt PeterAppellant 
Wiest, JamesAppellant 
Karlson, KeithAppellant 
Stulken, ToddAppellant 
Walker, ColleenAppellant 
Schnack, JayAppellant 
Runneals, BarbaraAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Jennings, RobynAppellant 
Thorp, KeithAppellant 
Parker, KellyAppellant 
Jarvis, Thomas JohnAppellant 
Huebner, DrewAppellant 
O'Brien, MaureenAppellant 
Kantorowicz, JamesAppellant 
Savel, WilliamAppellant 
Matz, NathanAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Bolling, TimAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Fahnberg, BobAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Johnson, RichardAppellant 
Mattey, NicoleAppellant 
Hernandez, AntonioAppellant 
Aldrich, KathyAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Grams, TeresaAppellant 
Sandberg, ChadAppellant 
Johnson, GretchenAppellant 
Hultman, JoanAppellant 
McIntire, Lisa RosemaryAppellant 
Goede, RonaldAppellant 
Fenn, SheriAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Westberg, AmyAppellant 
Sandeen, JanetAppellant 
Heurd, BeverlyAppellant 
Johnson, PaulAppellant 
Matz, JonAppellant 
Becken, Norman RossAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Rierson, GaryAppellant 
Matz, MichaelAppellant 
Stulken, KellyAppellant 
Lund, IV, Reuel IthielAppellant 
Stimson, Resa ReneeAppellant 
Harriman, Peter P.Appellant 
Gerbig, JaniceAppellant 
Bunce, MaryAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Harriman, TimAppellant 
Sandberg, MichaelAppellant 
Pramann, KellyAppellant 
Grams, KarenAppellant 
Vincent, MichelleAppellant 
Brickner, Peter S.AppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Kroneman, SherryAppellant 
Beam, DavidAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Fetsch, ToddAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Lane, John D.Appellant 
Beam, JamesAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Paschka, NatalieAppellant 
Grams, FrancisAppellant 
Carruthers, Peter JohnAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Loomis, Mark TimothyAppellant 
Thorp, DeloresAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Lewis, PaulineAppellant 
Ueno, Rebecca JoyAppellant 
Loomis, Timothy HowardAppellant 
Turner, BrianAppellant 
Cawthorne, PamAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Kantorowicz, RichardAppellant 
Lamp, JeffAppellant 
Reierson, GaleAppellant 
Verde Minerals, LLCAppellant 
Miller, DianneAppellant 
Boettcher, LoriAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Furlong, MichaelAppellantHon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hickman, MarkAppellant 
Vinje, Jr., John L.Appellant 
Kenyon, JeffAppellant 
Johnson, ThomasAppellant 
Johnson, PaulaAppellant 
Sandvig, MarvinAppellant 
Behlendorf, CandaceAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Loomis, Scott MatthewAppellant 
Jentoft-Johnson, VickiAppellant 
Anema, MaryAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Lamp, JamesAppellant 
Johnson, PattonAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. George Scott
Lee, Jill MarieAppellant 
Behlendorf, WayneAppellantHon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hardesty, Cynthia EellsAppellant 
Ness, ThomasAppellant 
Taubman, RichardAppellant 
Stulken, TonyAppellant 
Linnerooth, GloriaAppellant 
Lund, III, Reuel IthielAppellant 
Hoefs, CharlesAppellant 
Stimson, Steven D.Appellant 
Walker, JamesAppellant 
Christlieb, Frank L.AppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Koch, TheresaAppellant 
Bolling, JohnAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Falke, MaryAppellantHon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Frost, KennethAppellantHon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Hon. George Scott
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Peak, Pamela Von EschAppellant 
Townsend, Mary KayAppellant 
Luckemeyer, Christa GayAppellant 
Forsythe, RichardAppellantHon. George Scott
Hon. Walter J. Scott Jr.
Hon. Timothy A. Hootman
Hon. Douglas Chaves
Hon. Joshua R. Stein
Trial Court Information
343rd District Court 
Live Oak 
Honorable Janna K. Whatley 
L-20-0095-CV-C 
Lisa T. Riley