Twelfth Court of Appeals

Case: 12-25-00282-CV    
12-25-00282-CV
10/21/2025
Miscellaneous/other civil
Oncor Electric Delivery Company NTU, LLC 
Smith County Tax Assessor-Collector, Smith County, Chapel Hill ISD, Tyler ISD, Winona ISD, City of Lindale, City of Tyler, Smith County ESD 2, Arp ISD, City of Whitehouse, East Texas Municipal Utility District Number 1, Bullard ISD, Troup ISD, Whitehouse, ISD, City of Bullard, City of Troup, Smith County ESD1 and Tyler Jr. College District 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
West Publishing 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
09/16/2026Additional authorities filedAppellant
06/02/2026Reply brief filedAppellant
05/20/2026Appendix filedAppellee
05/20/2026Electronic brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
03/06/2026Appendix filedAppellant
03/06/2026Electronic brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
10/29/2026Motion for rehearing was not filed 
10/14/2026Opinion issuedReversed and Remanded
09/16/2026Additional authorities filed 
09/15/2026Submitted 
09/11/2026Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
09/11/2026Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
07/09/2026Set for submission on oral argument 
06/11/2026Internal memo 
06/11/2026Prescreened 
06/02/2026Reply brief filed 
05/20/2026Appendix filed 
05/20/2026Electronic brief filed - oral argument not requested 
05/20/2026Case ready to be set 
04/22/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief dispMotion or Writ Granted
04/20/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
04/09/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief dispMotion or Writ Granted
04/07/2026Notice filed 
04/02/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
03/06/2026Appendix filed 
03/06/2026Electronic brief filed - oral argument requested 
03/06/2026Letter filed 
03/04/2026Appearance of counsel 
02/04/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief dispMotion or Writ Granted
01/30/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
01/30/2026Letter filed 
01/08/2026Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief dispMotion or Writ Granted
12/29/2025Electronic Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
12/11/2025Electronic Clerks Record Filed 
12/04/2025Electronic Clerks Record Filed 
12/02/2025Reporters record filed 
10/31/2025Docketing statement filed 
10/27/2025Letter filed 
10/21/2025Notice of defect regarding perfection of the notice of appeal 
10/21/2025Fee paid 
10/21/2025Court packet sent to parties 
10/21/2025Notice of appeal filed in court of appeals 
10/03/2025Order entered 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
11/30/2026StatusPetition for review due in the Supreme Court
12/28/2026StatusMandate to Issue
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
City of TroupAppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Troup ISDAppelleeMr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
Tyler Jr. College DistrictAppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
City of WhitehouseAppelleeMr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
Van ISDAppellee 
City of LindaleAppelleeMr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
Smith County ESD 2AppelleeMr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. Ethan Ranis
City of BullardAppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Arp ISDAppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Oncor Electric Delivery Company NTU, LLCAppellantMs. Marnie A. McCormick
Mr. William E. Johnson
Ms. Stephanie Green
Mr. David Gilliland
Ms. Jo A. Merica
Chapel Hill ISDAppellee 
Tyler ISDAppellee 
Smith CountyAppellee 
East Texas Municipal Utility District Number 1AppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. John C. Hardy
Smith County ESD 1AppelleeMr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. John C. Hardy
Winona ISDAppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Smith County Tax Assessor-CollectorAppelleeMr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
City Of TylerAppelleeMr. John C. Hardy
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. Jim L. Lambeth
Bullard ISDAppellee 
Whitehouse ISDAppelleeMr. Jim L. Lambeth
Mr. Ethan Ranis
Mr. John C. Hardy
Trial Court Information
114th District Court 
Smith 
Honorable Austin R. Jackson 
24-3461-B 
Linda J. Webster