Eleventh Court of Appeals

Case: 11-24-00030-CV    
11-24-00030-CV
02/12/2024
Oil & Gas
Navigator Group et al. 
Susan Davis Van Dyke et al. 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
www.11thcoa.courts.state.tx.us 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
11/13/2024Additional authorities filedAppellee
07/18/2024Reply brief filedAppellant
06/28/2024Brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
04/29/2024Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
06/24/2026Case stored 
06/24/2026Mandate issued 
06/22/2026Petition for review was not filed 
04/14/2026Motion for extension of time to file petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtMotion or Writ Granted
04/13/2026Motion for extension of time to file petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
02/27/2026Memorandum opinion issuedAffirmed
11/20/2024Submitted 
11/20/2024Oral argument exhibits filed 
11/18/2024Appearance of counsel 
11/13/2024Additional authorities filed 
11/13/2024Appearance of counsel 
10/28/2024Document filed 
10/28/2024Document filed 
10/15/2024Set for submission on oral argument 
07/18/2024Reply brief filed 
07/01/2024Recusal of appellate court justice(s) 
07/01/2024Case ready to be set 
06/28/2024Brief filed - oral argument not requested 
06/28/2024Appearance of counsel 
05/30/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
05/29/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
04/29/2024Brief filed - oral argument requested 
03/28/2024Clerks record filed 
03/28/2024Motion disposedMotion or Writ Granted
03/18/2024Document filed 
03/18/2024Motion to transfer record filed 
03/11/2024Notification received that no record was taken 
03/06/2024Supplemental clerks record filed 
02/20/2024Docketing statement filed 
02/12/2024Recusal of appellate court justice(s) 
02/12/2024Fee paid 
02/12/2024Case Information Sheet from trial court clerk filed 
02/12/2024Case began in court of appeals 
02/09/2024Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
01/10/2024Judgment signed by trial court judge 
12/31/2018Document filed 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
06/24/2026Case StoredCase stored
06/24/2032RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
G&R Carr Enterprises LLCAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Steven C. Kiser
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Boyd Enterprises, Inc.AppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
Estate of Kay Elaine Keys, deceasedAppelleeMark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
James G. McClellan, Ind Executor of the Estate of Hayden J. Upchurch, deceasedAppelleeMarc S. Tabolsky
W. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Anwar, S. JavaidAppellantDerek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Eva M. Guzman
MTX Interests LPAppellantDerek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Eva M. Guzman
Terry S. Key trustee of the Terry S. Key Non-Exempt TrustAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Philip W. Johnson
Mark W. McBrayer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Jill Marie Stuckert, a/k/a Jill Marie WalkerAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Navigator Oil & Minerals, Inc.AppellantDemetri J. Economou
Derek L. Montgomery
Taylor Spalla  
Jillian Borreson
David E. Keltner
Harold L. Hensley, Jr.
Daniel, Michael J.AppellantEva M. Guzman
Derek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Angelo, Betty LouAppellantDerek L. Montgomery
Eva M. Guzman
Demetri J. Economou
Trustees of the Lucy G. Moses 12/24/58 TrustAppellee 
Van Dyke, Susan DavisAppelleeMarc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Bridgwater Jr., PrestonAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Deutsche Bank Trust Company, N.A. and Irving SitnickAppelleeKen K. Slavin
Freeport-McMoRan Oil & Gas LLCAppelleeJames J. Ormiston
The Ninety-Six CorporationAppellantDemetri J. Economou
Eva M. Guzman
Derek L. Montgomery
McDonald, GretchinAppellantWesley D. Lloyd
Discovery Exploration PartnershipAppellantEva M. Guzman
Derek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Deborah L. Alexander trustee of the DLA Child's TrustAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
W. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
PXP Producing Company LLCAppellee 
JP Morgan Chase Bank N.A. as trustee of the G.R. White Charitable Trust and as trustee of the Joy Lina White TrustAppellantDavid W. Lauritzen
Pam Stribling and John V. Price as heirs and seccessors of interest to Noble H. PriceAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Charles E. key trustee of the Charles E. Key Non-Exempt TrustAppelleeMark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
W. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Estate of Stephen L. Davis, deceasedAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Deutsche Bank Trust Company, N.A.AppelleeKen K. Slavin
Davis, Arthur B.AppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Viper Energy Partners LLCAppellant 
The Bishop-Windham Family Limited PartnershipAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Kennedy Minerals Ltd.AppellantEva M. Guzman
Derek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Dorchester Minerals, L.P.AppelleeDaniel Olds
Blake, Jr., Jack E.AppellantEva M. Guzman
Derek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Raymoind James Trust, N.A., trustees of the Edith Elizabeth Brasher 1986 Managament TrustAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
The Dillon FundAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Wood, BlakeAppellantEva M. Guzman
Demetri J. Economou
Derek L. Montgomery
Deutsche Bank Trust Company, NA. trustee of the William L. Hernstadt 1937 TrustAppelleeKen K. Slavin
Ryedale LLCAppelleeMark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
W. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
The Huffington FoundationAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
H & S Farms, Inc. AppellantDavid W. Lauritzen
Don M. Connally
William March Rice UniversityAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
W. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
McKenzie Ciliberto trustee of the MC Grandchild's TrustAppelleeMarc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Trustee of the Henry & Lucy Moses Foundation TrustAppellee 
Rick Ybarra as trusteeof the Logan Lee Blake TrustAppellantDemetri J. Economou
Eva M. Guzman
Derek L. Montgomery
Culley Ingram trustee of the CI Granchild's TrustAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Kerry Kantman trustee of the KK Grandchild's TrustAppelleeMark W. McBrayer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
W. Chris Boyer
Kayne Stroup as trustee of the Kayne Stroup TrustAppellantThomas L. Rees, Jr.
Howard W. Key trustee of the Howard W. Key Non-Exempt TrustAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Marc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
Sayre, PhillisAppellantWesley D. Lloyd
George Dan Mulkey and Thomas J. Mulkey trustees of the Mulkey Family Mineral Trust AppelleeMarc S. Tabolsky
Philip W. Johnson
W. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Haynes, JarvisAppellantWesley D. Lloyd
Sheryl Ann Huffner, f/k/a Ann Mulkey BellAppelleeW. Chris Boyer
Mark W. McBrayer
Philip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
C.T. White HeirsAppellee 
Covington Minerals, L.P.AppelleeBrian Kent Wunder
Dingus Investments, Inc.AppellantDemetri J. Economou
Derek L. Montgomery
Eva M. Guzman
Amber Lynette Stroup Rich as trustee of the Amber Stroup Rich TrustAppellantThomas L. Rees, Jr.
Blake Oil & Gas CorporationAppellantTaylor Spalla  
Harold L. Hensley, Jr.
Derek L. Montgomery
Jillian Borreson
Demetri J. Economou
Brendan . Fikes Family Partnership, Ltd.AppellantEva M. Guzman
Demetri J. Economou
Derek L. Montgomery
Skaar, Keith M.AppellantDemetri J. Economou
Derek L. Montgomery
Deutsche Bank Trust Company, N.A.and William H. Hernstadt trustees of the William H. Hernstadt Estate TrustAppelleeKen K. Slavin
Endeavor Energy Resources, L.P.AppelleePenelope Nicholson
Richard E. Booth
Steven C. Kiser
Lancaster, Jane R.AppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Amanda Kay Livingston trustee of the AKL Child's TrustAppelleeMarc S. Tabolsky
W. Chris Boyer
Philip W. Johnson
Mark W. McBrayer
Roger A. Key trustee of the Roger A. Key Non-Exempt TrustAppelleePhilip W. Johnson
Marc S. Tabolsky
Mark W. McBrayer
W. Chris Boyer
Angelo, Jr., ErnestAppellantDerek L. Montgomery
Demetri J. Economou
Eva M. Guzman
Trial Court Information
118th District Court 
Martin 
Honorable R. Shane Seaton, Judge 
6848 
Esther Van Blarcom, Court Reporter