Fifth Court of Appeals

Case: 05-23-00805-CV    
05-23-00805-CV
08/17/2023
Damages
Ruth Charmante Emmanuel 
Sandra Elena Ayala Garcia 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
West Publishing 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
08/13/2024Reply brief filedAppellant
08/12/2024Reply brief receivedAppellant
07/03/2024Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
05/02/2024Amended brief filedAppellant
02/16/2024Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
07/31/2026Sent to publisher 
07/11/2025Mandate issued 
04/30/2025Memorandum opinion issuedAffirmed/Reversed & Rendered
04/30/2025Retention time case file will be retainedDestroy
02/12/2025Submitted 
02/04/2025Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
02/04/2025Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
12/30/2024Set for submission on oral argument 
08/13/2024Reply brief filed 
08/13/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
08/12/2024Reply brief received 
07/19/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
07/03/2024Case ready to be set 
07/03/2024Brief filed - oral argument requested 
07/03/2024Appellees brief due 
06/03/2024Appellees brief due 
05/24/2024Order enteredMotion or Writ Granted
05/22/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
05/22/2024Appearance of counsel 
05/03/2024Amended brief due 
05/02/2024Amended brief filed 
04/03/2024Supplemental reporters record due 
04/01/2024Electronic Supplemental Reporter/Recorders Record Filed 
03/25/2024Response due 
03/17/2024Appellees brief due 
03/15/2024Order enteredMotion or Writ Granted
03/14/2024Motion to file amended brief filed 
02/16/2024Brief filed - oral argument requested 
02/16/2024Appellants brief due 
01/29/2024Order enteredMotion or Writ Granted
01/17/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
01/17/2024Appellants brief due 
12/18/2023Electronic Reporter/Recorders Record Filed 
11/27/2023Reporters record due 
11/17/2023Fee paid 
11/16/2023Order enteredMotion or Writ Granted
11/15/2023Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
11/14/2023Fee requested 
11/14/2023Reporters record due 
10/25/2023Order enteredOtherwise Disposed
09/06/2023No reporters record filed in civil case 
09/01/2023Record due 
08/30/2023Appearance of counsel 
08/29/2023Electronic Clerks Record Filed 
08/29/2023Order enteredMotion or Writ Granted
08/17/2023Motion for extension of time to file notice of appeal filed 
08/17/2023Fee requested 
08/17/2023Letter issued by the court 
08/17/2023Docketing statement due 
08/17/2023Notice of appeal filed in court of appeals 
08/16/2023Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
06/05/2023Motion for new trial was filed in the trial court 
05/04/2023Judgment signed by trial court judge 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
04/30/2031RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
07/11/2025Case StoredCase stored
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Emmanuel, Ruth CharmanteAppellantFrank G. Cawley  
Garcia, Sandra Elena AyalaAppelleeKirk L. Pittard  
Lucas S. Lafitte  
Ayesha Rafi
Kelly B. Gibbons
Shelby J. White
Trial Court Information
44th Judicial District Court 
Dallas 
Honorable Veretta Lynn Frazier 
DC-19-12220 
Crystal R. Brown