Supreme Court

Case: 05-0710    
05-0710
09/06/2005
Petition for Review/Cause under Rule 53.1
CHRISTUS HEALTH GULF COAST, CHRISTUS HEALTH SOUTHEAST TEXAS, GULF COAST DIVISION, INC., MEMORIAL HERMANN HOSPITAL SYSTEM AND BAPTIST HOSPITALS OF SOUTHEAST TEXAS 
AETNA, INC. AND AETNA HEALTH, INC. 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
10/12/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/11/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/10/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/09/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/08/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/07/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/30/2007Reply to Response to Motion for Rehearing filedRespondent Reply in support of mo/re.  On behalf of Aetna Inc., et al. (12)
10/26/2007Response to Motion for RehearingPetitioner Pet's response to mo/re.  On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al. (12)
10/08/2007Motion for RehearingRespondent's Motion for Rehearing of Cause filed Resp's mo/re.  On behalf of Aetna, Inc., et al. (12)
04/14/2006Reply BriefPetitioner Pet's reply brief on the merits on behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
03/30/2006Brief on the MeritsRespondent On behalf of Aetna Inc., et al.  Respondents' brief on the merits.
03/13/2006Amicus Curiae Brief receivedReceived (instead of filed) Amicus brief on behalf of United States Department of Health and Human Services.  Filed by Isaac J. Lidsky, U.S. Department of Justice, 950 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Washington DC 20530-0001.  Phone 202-514-3180.  Fax 202-514-9405.
02/24/2006Brief on the MeritsPetitioner Brief on the merits filed on behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast et al.
12/19/2005Reply to ResponsePetitioner Petitioner's reply to resp to pet/rev.  On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
12/05/2005Response to PetitionRespondent On behalf of Aetna Inc., et al.  Response to pet/rev.
09/15/2005Amicus Curiae Brief receivedReceived (instead of filed) On behalf of Texas Hospital Association in support of pet/rev.  Filed by Charles W. Bailey, PO Box 15587 Austin, TX 78761.  Phone 512-465-1000.  Fax 512-465-1090.
09/02/2005Appendix FiledPetitioner appendix attached.
09/02/2005Petition for ReviewPetitioner On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
10/12/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/11/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/10/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/09/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/08/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/07/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
01/28/2008Case Stored  G02 Row 4 D-3 (3 vols)
01/15/2008Mandate issued  Mandate & Cost Bill Issued
12/11/2007Letter sent to parties from Supreme Court - See Remarks  Letter correcting opinion sent with the following notation:  At page 9, a cite was added after the first sentence of the second paragraph.  The words "It considered:" were inserted, language was put into a block quote, an "Id." was added, and "(emphasis added)" was moved after "Id."  
11/30/2007Motion for Rehearing - DisposedDenied
10/30/2007Reply to Response to Motion for Rehearing filed  Reply in support of mo/re.  On behalf of Aetna Inc., et al. (12)
10/29/2007Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071009  Respondent's - Motion for Rehearing  Filed: 10/08/07
10/26/2007Response to Motion for Rehearing  Pet's response to mo/re.  On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al. (12)
10/18/2007Motion for Extension of Time to File Response disposedFiling granted Pets' m/e/t to file response to mo/re is granted.  Response is due n/l/t 3 p.m., October 29, 2007.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.  PLEASE NOTE that TEX. R. APP. P. 9.2(b) does not apply.
10/16/2007Motion for Extension of Time to File Response  Unopposed m/e/t to file response to mo/re.  On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al. (3)
10/09/2007Letter Filed  Response waiver to Motion for Rehearing, (3), filed on behalf of Petitioner Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
10/09/2007Supreme Court of Texas Requested Response  Requested response to mo/re due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 10/19/07; mlbx rule d/n/a
10/08/2007Case forwarded to Court 
10/08/2007Motion for Rehearing  Resp's mo/re.  On behalf of Aetna, Inc., et al. (12)
09/17/2007Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for Rehearing disposedFiling granted Resp's m/e/t to file mo/re is granted.  Mo/re is due October 8, 2007.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.
09/10/2007Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for Rehearing  Resp's unopposed m/e/t to file mo/re.  On behalf of Aetna Inc, et al.
08/31/2007Court approved judgment sent to attorneys of recordIssued
08/31/2007Opinion issuedCourt of Appeals' judgment reversed; cause remanded to trial court
12/06/2006Oral argument   argued on behalf of petitioners by Scott M. Clearman;  argued on behalf of respondents by John B. Shely;  argued on behalf of amicus curiae, U.S. Dept. of Health & Human Servs. by Isaac J. Lidsky
10/06/2006Motion to Argue disposedFiling granted Motion by amicus United States Department of Health and Human Services for leave to participate in oral argument granted
09/07/2006Motion to Argue filed  Motion by amicus United States Department of Health and Human Services for leave to participate in oral argument.  
Isaac Lidsky
09/01/2006Case set for oral argumentCase set for oral argument OA set for 12/6/06 @ 9:00 a.m.
09/01/2006Petition for Review granted 
09/01/2006Petition for Review disposedFiling granted
04/18/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071008  Petitioner's Reply Brief on the Merits 4/14/06
04/14/2006Reply Brief  Pet's reply brief on the merits on behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
04/10/2006Call received  call rec'd from pet saying letter granting resp m/e/t says their reply is due 4/14/06 but website says reply due 4/11/06.  pet was told reply br is due 4/14/06 as letter stated; calendar changed to reflect correct date
04/03/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071007  Respondents' Brief on the Merits 3/30/06
04/03/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071006  Amicus Curiae Brief of U.S.Dept. of Health & Human Services Rec:  3/13/06
04/03/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071005  Response to Petition for Review 12/5/05
03/30/2006Brief on the Merits  On behalf of Aetna Inc., et al.  Respondents' brief on the merits.
03/30/2006Miscellaneous motion disposed. See Remarks.Filing granted Motion for amicus Isaac Lidsky to appear pro hac vice granted
03/30/2006Miscellaneous motion disposed. See Remarks.Filing granted Daniel M. Castillo's motion in support of Isaac Lidsky's motion pro hac vice granted
03/23/2006Miscellaneous Motion  Daniel M. Castillo's motion in support of Isaac Lidsky's motion pro hac vice.
03/22/2006Miscellaneous Motion  Motion for amicus Isaac Lidsky to appear pro hac vice. (3)
03/20/2006Phone call from Clerk's Office  To Mr. Isaac Lidsky to inquire whether he intends to file a motion pro hac vice.  The motion will be filed ASAP.
03/15/2006Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted resp's m/e/t to file brief on the merits is granted;  resp's br due 3/27/06;  pets' br due 4/11/06;  all briefs due n/l/t 3 pm, TRAP 9.2(b) d/n/a
03/14/2006Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  Unopposed motion for extension of time to file response brief on the merits filed on behalf of Aetna Inc. et al.  
03/13/2006Amicus Curiae Brief received  Amicus brief on behalf of United States Department of Health and Human Services.  Filed by Isaac J. Lidsky, U.S. Department of Justice, 950 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Washington DC 20530-0001.  Phone 202-514-3180.  Fax 202-514-9405.
02/28/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071004  Petitioners' Brief on the Merits 2/24/06
02/24/2006Brief on the Merits  Brief on the merits filed on behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast et al.
02/08/2006Case Record Filed   inventory in remarks.
02/08/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071003  Amicus Curiae Brief of TX Hospital Association Rec:  9/15/05
02/03/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071002  Petitioners' Reply Brief 12/19/05
02/03/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05071001  Petition for Review 9/2/05
01/26/2006Record Requested in Case 
01/25/2006Brief on the Merits Ordered  Brief on the merits requested:  Pet br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 2/24/06, Rsp br due 3/16/06; Reply br due 3/31/06; mlbx rule d/n/a
12/19/2005Reply to Response  Petitioner's reply to resp to pet/rev.  On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
12/06/2005Additional Copies received  Original of the response to pet/rev. filed yesterday.  Back dated to 12/5/05
12/05/2005Phone call from Clerk's Office  Call made to Mr. Kendall Gray requesting the original to the response to pet/rev.  He will get that to us.
12/05/2005Response to Petition  On behalf of Aetna Inc., et al.  Response to pet/rev.
11/03/2005Supreme Court of Texas Requested Response  Requested response to petition for review due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 12/5/05; mlbx rule d/n/a
10/04/2005Case forwarded to Court 
09/15/2005Amicus Curiae Brief received  On behalf of Texas Hospital Association in support of pet/rev.  Filed by Charles W. Bailey, PO Box 15587 Austin, TX 78761.  Phone 512-465-1000.  Fax 512-465-1090.
09/02/2005Appendix Filed  appendix attached.
09/02/2005Petition for Review  On behalf of Christus Health Gulf Coast, et al.
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
01/28/2008Case StoredCase stored.G02 Row 4 D-3 (3 vols)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Christus Health Gulf CoastPetitionerMr. David E. Warden
Mr. Eric Paul Chenoweth
Mr. Brian D. Walsh
Mr. Scott M. Clearman
Texas Gulf Coast HMO, Inc.Other interested party Mr. John B. Scott
Texas Hospital AssociationAmicus CuriaeMr. Charles W. Bailey
United States Department of Health and Human ServicesAmicus CuriaeMr. Isaac J. Lidsky
Mr. Daniel Manuel Castillo
Aetna, Inc.RespondentMr. Kendall Matthew Gray
Mr. Jeffrey D. Migit
Mr. Dimitri Zgourides
Mr. John B. Shely
Court of Appeals Information:
Affirmed [duplicate 1] 
167 SW3d 879, 04-14-05 
14th Court of Appeals 
Honorable Leslie Brock Yates 
Trial Court Information
157th District Court 
Harris 
Honorable Randall W. Wilson 
2002-39946