Supreme Court

Case: 05-0169    
05-0169
03/07/2005
Second Petition for Review/Cause under Rule 53.1
FARMERS GROUP, INC., ET AL. 
JAN LUBIN, GILBERTO VILLANUEVA, AND MICHAEL PALADINO 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
10/19/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/18/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/17/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/16/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/15/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/14/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/13/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/12/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/11/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/10/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/09/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/08/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/07/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
04/03/2006Reply BriefPetitioner Reply brief on the merits filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al.  (seq #2)
04/03/2006Reply BriefPetitioner Pet #1 Farmers Group, et al's reply brief on the merits.
03/15/2006Amended Brief filedRespondent Amended brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.
02/27/2006Brief on the MeritsRespondent Respondent's brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.
01/24/2006Appendix FiledRespondent Appendix to response bom.  On behalf of Jan Lubin. (12)
01/24/2006Brief on the MeritsRespondent Response brief on the merits.  On behalf of Jan Lubin.
01/03/2006Appendix FiledRespondent Appendix to resp bom.  On behalf of Gerald and Lesly K. Hooks.
01/03/2006Brief on the MeritsRespondent Response brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gerald Hooks and Lesly K. Hooks.
12/07/2005Appendix FiledPetitioner Appendix to brief on the merits filed on behalf of Pet #2, The State of Texas et al.
12/07/2005Brief on the MeritsPetitioner Brief on the merits filed on behalf of pet #2,  The State of Texas et al.  
12/07/2005Appendix FiledPetitioner Appendix in support of brief on the merits filed on behalf of Pet #1 Farmers Group Inc. et al.
12/07/2005Brief on the MeritsPetitioner Brief on the merits filed on behalf of pet #1  Farmers Group Inc. et al.  
06/28/2005Response to PetitionRespondent Response to petitions for review filed on behalf of Jan Lubin
06/28/2005Reply to ResponsePetitioner State's reply to response to pet/rev. (seq#2)
06/21/2005Reply to ResponsePetitioner Reply to response to pet. for review filed on behalf of Farmers Group Inc.  (seq #1)
06/06/2005Response to PetitionRespondent On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.  Response to petitions for review.
03/07/2005Appendix FiledPetitioner Appendix to pet. for review filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al. (seq #2)
03/07/2005Petition for Review #2Petitioner Pet. for review filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al.  (seq #2)
03/07/2005Appendix FiledPetitioner Appendix to pet. for review.  (seq #1)
03/07/2005Petition for ReviewPetitioner Pet. for review filed on behalf of Farmers Group Inc.   (seq #1)
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
10/19/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/18/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/17/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/16/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/15/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/14/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/13/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/12/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/11/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/10/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/09/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/08/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
10/07/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
07/26/2007Case Stored  G01/6-H-1
07/13/2007Case remanded and record returned to the Court of Appeals.  Case remanded and record returned to the 3rd Court of Appeals.
07/13/2007Mandate issued  Mandate and cost bill issued.
04/27/2007Court approved judgment sent to attorneys of recordIssued
04/27/2007Concurring and Dissenting Opinion deliveredIssued
04/27/2007Opinion issuedCourt of Appeals' judgment reversed; remanded to Court of Appeals
01/25/2007Oral argument   argued on behalf of petitioners by Marcy Hogan Greer and David C. Mattax;  argued on behalf of respondents by Russell S. Post
11/06/2006Address Change   Change of address for attorney Dwight E. Jefferson. (1)  Updated CM.
10/27/2006Motion to Recuse disposedFiling dismissed as moot Joint motion to certify recusal of justice and seek appointment of temporary replacement justice dismissed as moot
10/27/2006Case set for oral argumentCase set for oral argument OA set for 1/25/07 @ 9 a.m.; Time allotted - 20/20 minutes
10/27/2006Petition for Review granted 
10/27/2006Petition for Review disposedFiling granted
10/27/2006Case set for oral argumentCase set for oral argument OA set for 1/25/07 @ 9 a.m.; Time allotted - 20/20 minutes
10/27/2006Petition for Review granted 
10/27/2006Petition for Review disposedFiling granted
04/04/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016911  State - Petitioner's Reply Brief on the Merits 4/3/06
04/04/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016910  Farmers - Petitioner's Reply Brief on the Merits 4/3/06
04/03/2006Reply Brief  Reply brief on the merits filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al.  (seq #2)
04/03/2006Reply Brief  Pet #1 Farmers Group, et al's reply brief on the merits.
03/21/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016909  Villanueva & Paladino - Respondents' Amended Brief on the Merits 3/15/06
03/17/2006Motion for leave to file brief disposedFiling granted Rsp's unopposed m/f/l to file amended brief on the merits granted.  Rsp br filed on 3/15/06.
03/15/2006Amended Brief filed  Amended brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.
03/15/2006Motion for Leave to File Amended Brief filed  Respondents' unopposed motion for leave to file amended brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.
03/10/2006Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted Joint unopposed m/e/t to file reply brief on the merits granted.  Reply br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 4/3/06; mlbx d/n/a.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.
03/06/2006Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  Joint unopposed motion to extend time to file reply brief on the merits filed on behalf Farmers Group Inc.  (pet #1)
02/28/2006Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016908  Villanueva & Paladino - Respondents' Brief on the Merits 2/27/06
02/27/2006Brief on the Merits  Respondent's brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.
01/31/2006Reply to Response to Motion  Joint reply of pet #1 Farmers and Pet #2 The State of Texas in further support of joint motion to certify recusal of Justice and seek appointment of temporary replacement justice.
01/31/2006Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted Rsp Gilberto Villanueva & Michael Paladino's unopposed 2nd m/e/t to file brief on the merits granted.  Response br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 2/27/06; Reply br due 3/14/06; mlbx rule d/n/a.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.
01/27/2006Call received  Call rec'd from atty., David Maddox, regarding his intent to file reply to response to motion.  Will be filed by Tuesday.
01/27/2006Call received  Farmers will be filing a reply, possibly joint  to the response to motion by Tuesday, Jan 31, 2006.  Rec'd call from atty, Marci Greer.  
01/26/2006Response to Motion filed  Response to joint motion for temporary replacement justice filed on behalf of Jan Lubin.  Lubin seeks to adopt the response of Paladino and Villanueva  
01/26/2006Response to Motion filed  Response to joint motion for temporary replacement justice filed on behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino
01/24/2006Appendix Filed  Appendix to response bom.  On behalf of Jan Lubin. (12)
01/24/2006Brief on the Merits  Response brief on the merits.  On behalf of Jan Lubin.
01/24/2006Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  Respondent Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino unopposed second m/e/t to file brief on the merits.
01/20/2006Motion to Recuse filed  Joint motion to certify recusal of justice and seek appointment of temporary replacement justice filed on behalf of Farmers Group Inc. et al.
01/05/2006Call received  Both replies to resp bom will be due on Feb. 10.  S/W pet's atty and comfirmed for him.
01/04/2006Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted Rsp's m/e/t to file brief on the merits granted.  Rsp br was filed on 1/3/06.
01/04/2006Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  M/e/t to file response brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gerald and Lesly K. Hooks.
01/03/2006Appendix Filed  Appendix to resp bom.  On behalf of Gerald and Lesly K. Hooks.
01/03/2006Brief on the Merits  Response brief on the merits.  On behalf of Gerald Hooks and Lesly K. Hooks.
12/28/2005Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted Resps' unopposed joint m/e/t to file rsp brief on the merits granted.  Rsp br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 1/26/06; Reply br due 2/10/06; mlbx rule d/n/a.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.  (Justice Wainwright not sitting)
12/22/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  Unopposed joint motion for extension of time to file brief on the merits filed on behalf of Lubin, Villanueva and Paladino.
12/12/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016907  Farmers - Petitioner's Brief on the Merits 12/7/05
12/07/2005Appendix Filed  Appendix to brief on the merits filed on behalf of Pet #2, The State of Texas et al.
12/07/2005Brief on the Merits  Brief on the merits filed on behalf of pet #2,  The State of Texas et al.  
12/07/2005Appendix Filed  Appendix in support of brief on the merits filed on behalf of Pet #1 Farmers Group Inc. et al.
12/07/2005Brief on the Merits  Brief on the merits filed on behalf of pet #1  Farmers Group Inc. et al.  
12/01/2005Motion to Recuse disposedFiling dismissed as moot Motion to disqualify or recuse J. Willett dismissed as moot.  (Justice Willett not sitting)
11/22/2005Motion to Recuse filed  Motion to disqualify or recuse filed on behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino
10/31/2005Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted 2nd joint unopposed m/e/t to file brief on the merits granted.  Pets br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 12/7/05; Rsp br due 12/27/05; Reply br due 1/11/06; mlbx rule d/n/a
10/27/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  Second Joint unopposed motion to extend time to file opening briefs on the merits.  On behalf of pet #1 Farmers and Pet #2 State of Texas.
09/29/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016906  Lubin - Response to Petitions for Review 6/28/05
09/21/2005Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Filing granted Joint 1st unopposed m/e/t to file pets brief on the merits granted.  Pet#1 & Pet#2's briefs due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 11/7/05; Rsp br due 11/28/05; Reply br due 12/13/05; mlbx rule d/n/a.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.
09/19/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed  Joint first unopposed m/e/t to file brief on the merits.  On behalf of petitioner #1 Farmers Group, et al. and petitioner #2 State of Texas.
09/19/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016905 Villanueva & Paladino - Response to Petitions for Review 6/6/05
09/19/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016904  Farmers - Petitioner's Reply Brief 6/21/05
09/19/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016903  Farmers - Pet for Review 3/7/05
09/14/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016901  State's Petition for Review 3/7/05
09/14/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05016902  State - Petitioner's Reply Brief   6/28/05
09/09/2005Case Record Filed   inventory in remarks.
09/07/2005Record Requested in Case 
09/06/2005Brief on the Merits Ordered  Brief on the merits requested:  Pets br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 10/6/05; Rsp br due 10/26/05; Reply br due 11/10/05; mlbx rule d/n/a
07/25/2005Notice from Counsel of a change in address  Change of address for respondent's attorney Steven M. Smoot.  updated cm.
07/20/2005Letter Filed  Letter from one of the State of Texas attorney Jack Hohengarten asking if he could please start receiving notice in this case.  updated CM giving him notice.
06/28/2005Response to Petition  Response to petitions for review filed on behalf of Jan Lubin
06/28/2005Reply to Response  State's reply to response to pet/rev. (seq#2)
06/21/2005Reply to Response  Reply to response to pet. for review filed on behalf of Farmers Group Inc.  (seq #1)
06/17/2005MET to file reply disposed ofFiling granted Pet State's unopposed m/e/t to file reply brief due June 28, 2005.  Further requests for extensions of time will not be considered.
06/17/2005Motion to Extend Time to File Reply filed  Unopposed motion to extend time to file reply filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al.  (seq #2)
06/07/2005Case forwarded to Court 
06/07/2005Case forwarded to Court 
06/06/2005Response to Petition  On behalf of Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino.  Response to petitions for review.
05/09/2005Motion for Extension of Time disposed.Form Letter sent in response to motion for extension of time Standard letter sent in response to Rsp Jan Lubins' unopposed 2nd m/e/t to file response to petitions for review.
05/06/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response  Respondent Jan Lubins' unopposed second m/e/t to file response to pet/rev.
05/04/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response disposedFiling granted Respondents' unopposed 2nd m/e/t to file response to petition for review granted.  Response to petition for review due June 6, 2005.  Further requests for extension of time will be disfavored.
05/03/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response  Gilberto Villanueva and Michael Paladino unopposed second m/e/t to file response to petitions for review.
04/04/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response disposedFiling granted Rsp Jan Lubin's m/e/t to file response to petition for review granted.  Response due May 6, 2005.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.
04/04/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response disposedFiling granted Rsp Gilberto Villanueva, et al's m/e/t to file response to petition for review granted.  Response due May 6, 2005.  Further requests for extensions of time will be disfavored.
04/01/2005Address Change   Address change submitted on behalf of att., Philip K. Maxwell, 1717 West Avenue, Austin, Tx., ph # 512-457-1111, fx # 512-692-9524 (updated in CM)
03/31/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response  Unopposed motion for extension of time to file response to pet. for review filed on behalf of Gilbreto Villanueva and Michael Paladino
03/31/2005Motion for Extension of Time to File Response  Motion for extension of time to file response filed on behalf of Jan Lubin.
03/21/2005Response Waiver filed  On behalf of Leslie Hooks et vir. (2)
03/07/2005Appendix Filed  Appendix to pet. for review filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al. (seq #2)
03/07/2005Petition for Review #2  Pet. for review filed on behalf of The State of Texas et al.  (seq #2)
03/07/2005Appendix Filed  Appendix to pet. for review.  (seq #1)
03/07/2005Petition for Review  Pet. for review filed on behalf of Farmers Group Inc.   (seq #1)
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
07/26/2007Case StoredCase stored.G01/6-H-1
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Hooks, GeraldRespondentMr. Joseph C. Blanks
Fire Underwriters AssociationPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Farmer Group Inc.PetitionerMr. Richard N. Carrell
Mr. Gerard G. Pecht
Mr. Layne E. Kruse
Ms. Marcy Hogan Greer
Mr. M. Scott Incerto
Ms. Mary S. Dietz
Ms. Katherine D. Mackillop
Mr. Layne E. Kruse
Truck Insurance ExchangePetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
State of Texas PetitionerMs. Amy Warr
Mr. Paul D. Carmona
Mr. David C. Mattax
Mr. James R. Wenzel
Mr. Edward D. Burbach
Mr. Barry Ross McBee
Mr. Jeff M. Graham
Mr. Gregory Abbott
Ms. Lisa Royce Eskow
Mr. James R. Wenzel
Mr. John M. Hohengarten
Mr. Rafael Edward Cruz
Hooks, Lesly K.RespondentMr. Joseph C. Blanks
Farmers Insurance ExchangePetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Texas Farmers Insurance CompanyPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Paladino, MichaelRespondentMr. David H. Burrow
Mid-Century Insurance CompanyPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Farmers Texas County Mutual Insurance CompanyPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Mid-Century Insurance Company of TexasPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Truck Underwriters AssociationPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Villanueva, GilbertoRespondentMr. Russell S. Post
Mr. David H. Burrow
Mr. Dwight E. Jefferson
Mr. David W. Jones
Farmers Underwriters AssociationPetitionerMs. Marcy Hogan Greer
Lubin, JanRespondentMr. Michael T. Gallagher
Mr. Stephen L. McCleery
Mr. Philip K. Maxwell
Mr. Daniel M. Downey
Mr. Joe K. Longley
Court of Appeals Information:
Reversed and Remanded 
157 SW3d 113, 01-21-05 
3rd Court of Appeals 
Honorable David E. Puryear 
Trial Court Information
261st District Court 
Travis 
Honorable Scott H. Jenkins 
GV202501