Supreme Court

Case: 05-0145    
05-0145
02/28/2005
Probable juris noted
ALVARADO INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT, ET AL. 
SHIRLEY NEELEY, TEXAS COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION, ET AL. 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
10/07/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
12/07/2005Motion for Rehearing for pet #2 Appellee in case Alvarado Appellees' motion for rehearing.  (all documents found in 04-1144)
12/07/2005Motion for RehearingAppellee's motion for rehearing of a cause filed Edgewood appellees' mo/re.  All copies filed in 04-1144.
04/15/2005Brief on the MeritsAppellant in case Brief filed on behalf of Alvarado
03/15/2005Response to PetitionAppellee in case On behalf of Shirley Neeley, et al.
02/28/2005Direct Appeal filedAppellant in case Direct appeal filed on behalf of Alvarado ISD
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
10/07/2020Brief from database  Refer to file-stamped date on the document for the actual file date.
01/12/2006Case Stored  G01 (1) FOLDER CONSOL. W/04-1144  Bin M3
12/21/2005Mandate issued  Mandate and cost bill issued in causes 04-1144, 05-0145, and 05-0148.
12/16/2005Motion for Rehearing - DisposedDenied with Justice not sitting.
12/16/2005Motion for Rehearing - DisposedDenied with Justice not sitting.
12/07/2005Case forwarded to Court 
12/07/2005Motion for Rehearing for pet #2   Alvarado Appellees' motion for rehearing.  (all documents found in 04-1144)
12/07/2005Case forwarded to Court 
12/07/2005Motion for Rehearing  Edgewood appellees' mo/re.  All copies filed in 04-1144.
11/22/2005Court approved judgment sent to attorneys of recordIssued
11/22/2005Opinion issuedIssued
08/31/2005Document received (See Remarks)  On behalf of Americans for Prosperity Texas (AFP).  Filed on behalf of Marc Levin w/ Potts & Reilly, L.L.P. 401 West 15th Street, Suite 850, Austin, Texas 78701-1665.  Phone 512-469-7474.  Fax 512-469-7480.  Portable 713-906-1833.  Filed on 04-1144.
08/05/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Amicus brief of Hispanic Council for Reform and Educational Options submitted by atty., Marc A. Levin, 401 West 15th Street, Suite 850, Austin, Tx.,   ph # 512-469-7474; fax 512-469-7480  
07/29/2005Document received (See Remarks)  The Edgewood Appellants post submission brief to clarify their position on two issues raised during oral argument.
07/11/2005Document received (See Remarks)  West Orange-Cove's post-submission letter to clarify issues raised during argument.
07/06/2005Document received (See Remarks)  On behalf of Americans for Prosperity - Texas.  Filed by Marc Levin of Potts & Reilly, L.L.P. 401 W. 15th Street, Suite 850 Austin TX 78701.  Phone 512-469-7474.  Fax 512-469-7480
07/06/2005Oral argument   Argued for the State, et al., as appellants, by R. Ted Cruz;  
argued for WOC ISD, et al., as Appellees, by John David Thompson III;  
argued on behalf of Edgewood I.S.D., et al., as appellees, by David G. Hinojosa;  
argued on behalf Alvarado I.S.D., et al., as appellees, by Randal B. Wood.
07/06/2005Document received (See Remarks)  West Orange-Cove oarl argument exhibits.
07/01/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Amicus brief submitted on behalf of American Civil Liberties Union, National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, and League of United Latin American Citizens by att., Sylvia Ann Mayer, 700 Louisiana, Suite 1600, Houston, Texas   77002 ph # 7135465000, fx # 713-2249511
07/01/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Amicus Curiae brief submitted on behalf of The Earl Carl Institute for Legal and Social Policy by atty., Carroll G. Robinson, 3100 Cleburne, Office 108, Houston, Tx.  ph # 713-313-1139, fx #713-313-1153  
06/30/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Amicus brief submitted on behalf of Texas Associations of School Boards Legal Assistant Fund by att., Deborah G. Hankinson, 2305 Cedar Springs, Suite 230, Dallas, Texas  75201 ph # 214-754-9190  fx # 214-754-9140
06/28/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Motion to amend order allotting time for oral argument and for rebuttal opportunity filed on behalf of Edgewood ISD et al. (2 copies only)
06/24/2005Case set for oral argumentCase set for oral argument
06/22/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Edgewood ISD, et al. files letter in response to Court's request for time allocations in the oral argument scheduled 7/6/05.
06/21/2005Document received (See Remarks)  The State's unopposed motion to permit four attorneys to be seated at counsel table.
06/21/2005Document received (See Remarks)  School districts joint unopposed motion to allow additional counsel to sit at counsel table
06/20/2005Document received (See Remarks)  On behalf of the Texas Federation of Teachers.  Filed by Martha P. Owen of Deats, Durst, Owen & Levy, PLLC, 1204 San Antonio St. Ste 203, Austin TX 78701.  Ph 512/479-6200, Fax 512/479-7896.
06/20/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Letter in response to Court's request for the parties' views on the amount and allocation of oral argument time.  On behalf of Alvarado.
06/20/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Letter in response to Court's request for the parties' views on the amount and allocation of oral argument time and the State's letter of June 17 setting forth its views.  On behalf of West Orange, et al.
06/09/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Nina Cortell is now the lead counsel for West Grove.  Charles Orr is no longer w/ Haynes & Boone.  Updated CM to give Ms. Cortell notice. (original filed in 04-1144)
06/06/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Reply brief on the merits on behalf of Edgewood.
06/06/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Reply brief of Alvarado appellants.
06/02/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Edgewood sur-reply to joint reply of State and West Orange-Cove plaintiffs in support of joint motion to file trial exhibits and transript in electronic format and to file other materials to assist the Court.
05/31/2005Document received (See Remarks)  document rec'd: reply brief filed on behalf of The Texas Education Agency et al.
05/31/2005Document received (See Remarks)  document rec'd: unopposed motion for leave to file reply brief in excess of page limit filed on behalf of The Texas Education Agency et al.
05/31/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Document rec'd: Joint reply  in support of motion to file trial exhibits and transcript in electronic format and to file other materials to assist the court filed on behalf  West Orange Cove and The State.
05/31/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Document rec'd: response and objection to joint motion to file trial exhibits and transcript in electronic format and to file other materials to assist the court filed on behalf of Edgewood.  
05/27/2005Letter Filed  Letter filed requesting a change in the style.  Style should read: Alvarado Independent School District et al. v Shirley Neeley et al.
05/27/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Joint motion by the West Orange Cove-Plaintiffs, The Alvarado  Plaintiffs, and The State to file trial exhibits and transcript in electronic format and to file other materials to assist the court.   Includes exhibits that are listed in case 04-1104.
05/26/2005Letter Filed  Letter filed requesting a change in the style of the case to read: Alvarado I.S.D et al. v. Shirley Neeley, et al.  
05/20/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Appellees' brief on merits.  On behalf of Shirley Neeley, et al.  (app bom's for case numbers 05-0145 & 05-0148).  Orig and copies filed in 04-1144.
05/12/2005Document received (See Remarks)  On behalf Edgewood, et al.  Brief of appellees. original and copies filed in 04-1144.
05/09/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Alvarado appellees' brief on merits.  orig filed in 04-1144.
05/09/2005Document received (See Remarks)  West Orange-Cove brief on the merits (12) and appendix (12).
04/22/2005Cases consolidated by Supreme Court  Consolidation of cases 04-1144, 05-0145, and 05-0148;  file all briefs in 04-1144.
04/22/2005Case set for oral argumentCase set for oral argument set for oral argument July 6, 2005.
04/18/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014508  Alvarado's Appellants' Brief   4/15/05
04/15/2005Brief on the Merits  Brief filed on behalf of Alvarado
03/28/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014507  Edgewood's Letter Regarding Consolidation 3/28/05
03/28/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014506  The State's Clarification Letter Regarding Consolidation 3/24/05
03/28/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014505  W.O.C.'s Letter Regarding Consolidation 3/25/05
03/28/2005Letter Filed  Letter from Alvarado appellants regarding consolidation of the state's appeal in 04-1144, Alvarados' appeal in 05-0145 and the Edgewood appellants' in 05-0148.
03/28/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Edgewoods response to courts request to consider consolidation.  Edgewood agrees w/ consolidation of 05-0148 but does not agree w/ consolidation of 04-1144.
03/25/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Letter filed on behalf of West Orange Cove addressing the question of whether the cases should be consolidated.
03/24/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Letter where the State wishes to clarify letter filed by them on 03/21/05 that 05-0145 & 05-0148 should be consolidated also for the purposes of briefing.
03/22/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014504  The State's Letter Regarding Consolidation   3/21/05
03/21/2005Document received (See Remarks)  Letter filed in compliance with request from Court on weather or not case # 04-1144, 05-0145 & 05-0148 should be consolidated.  On behalf of Shirley Neeley, et al.
03/16/2005Brief on the Merits Ordered  Brief on the merits requested:  Ants br due n/l/t 3:00 p.m. on 4/15/05; Apes br due 5/20/05; Reply br due 6/6/05; mlbx rule d/n/a.
03/16/2005Petition Granted/Date and time for oral argument are yet to be determined.The date and time for oral argument are yet to be determined. The date and time for oral argument are yet to be determined.
03/16/2005Direct Appeal Grant 
03/16/2005Direct Appeal disposedJurisdiction noted in Direct Appeal.
03/15/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014503  Response to Alvarado Statement of Jurisdiction 3/15/05
03/15/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014502  Appellants' Statement of Jurisdiction   3/15/05
03/15/2005Response to Petition  On behalf of Shirley Neeley, et al.
03/15/2005Statement of Jurisidiction  On behalf of Alvarado I.S.D., et al.
03/08/2005Notice received  Letter from ant's asking the Court to please give Mr. Mark Trachtenberg and George Bramlett both of Haynes & Boone, notice on future correspondence in this case.  Updated CM. (1)
03/01/2005Electronic copies of brief posted to website  #05014501  Notice of Appeal Filed:  2/28/05
03/01/2005Phone call from Clerk's Office  Call made to att., Doug Ray, regarding unpaid filing fee for direct appeal.  They will mail in fee or have courier walk it in.  
03/01/2005Notice requesting filing fee  Fee request sent to att., Doug W. Ray, regarding unpaid filing fee for direct appeal, $125.00
02/28/2005Docketing statement filed  Docketing statement filed on behalf of Alvarado ISD
02/28/2005Direct Appeal filed  Direct appeal filed on behalf of Alvarado ISD
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
01/12/2006Case StoredCase stored.G01/EX-G-1 (1) FOLDER CONSOL. W/04-1144 Bin M3
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Edgewood I.S.D et al. AppellantMs. Nina Perales
Mr. David G. Hinojosa
Neeley, ShirleyAppelleeMr. Jeffrey L. Rose
Ms. Danica Lynn Milios
Mr. Joseph David Hughes
Ms. Merle Hoffman Dover
Ms. Amy Warr
Mr. Gregory Abbott
Ms. Shelley Nieto Dahlberg
Mr. Barry Ross McBee
Mr. Edward D. Burbach
Mr. Rafael Edward Cruz
Alvarado ISDAppellantMr. Randall B. Wood
Mr. Doug W. Ray
The Texas State Board of Education AppelleeMr. Rafael Edward Cruz
Strayhorn, Carole KeetonAppelleeMr. Rafael Edward Cruz
Texas Federation of TeachersAmicus CuriaeMs. Martha Powell Owen
West Orange Cove Consolidated Independent School District et al. AppellantMs. Nina Cortell
Mr. George W. Bramblett Jr.
Mr. Charles Orr
Mr. Kirk Lane Worley
Mr. Philip D. Fraissinet
Mr. John David Thompson
Mr. Mark R. Trachtenberg
Americans for ProsperityAmicus CuriaeMr. Marc A. Levin
Court of Appeals Information:
 
 
 
 
Trial Court Information
250th District Court 
Travis 
Honorable John K. Dietz 
GV-100528