Fourth Court of Appeals

Case: 04-19-00771-CV    
04-19-00771-CV
10/29/2019
Contract
Kent B. Hoffman, Susan Hoffman Binieck, E. Peter Hoffman Jr., and Marni H. Cooney 
Andrew M. Thomson; CDG Peeler Family Limited Partnership; Cynthia L. Littlefield; The Dick Family Irrevocable Trust; Gordon G. Thomson; Jane Elizabeth Erzen; Larry Wayne McCarty; Linda M. Ball; Michael David Dick; North Thomson Oil and Gas LP; Patricia P. Fleming; Paul W. Peeler Family Limited Partnership; Sandra Shannon Collins; Shannon Family Trust; Thomson Oil & Gas Investments LP; Coconut Point ST, LLC; Coconut Point OE, LLC; 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
West Publishing 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
03/17/2026Additional authorities filedAppellee
09/26/2024Brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
08/07/2024Reply brief filedAppellant
05/15/2024Amended brief filedAppellee
02/12/2024Amended brief filedAppellant
04/05/2022Amicus curiae brief received 
06/30/2020Reply brief filedAppellant
05/04/2020Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
05/04/2020Brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
02/03/2020Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
10/09/2026Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
08/25/2026Order entered 
08/25/2026Motion for rehearing disposedMotion or Writ Denied
07/16/2026Reply to response or motion filed 
07/08/2026Response filed 
06/04/2026Order entered 
06/04/2026Motion for extension of time to file response disposedGrant motion
06/01/2026Letter filed 
05/26/2026Motion for extension of time to file response filed 
05/13/2026Order entered 
05/04/2026Motion for rehearing filed 
04/01/2026Order entered 
04/01/2026Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing disposedGrant motion
03/20/2026Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing filed 
03/18/2026Opinion issuedReversed and Rendered
03/17/2026Additional authorities filed 
09/17/2025Response filed 
09/11/2025Motion filed 
09/10/2025Submitted 
08/21/2025Set for submission on briefs 
08/14/2025Letter filed 
04/01/2025Letter filed 
03/26/2025Letter filed 
09/26/2024Brief filed - oral argument not requested 
09/20/2024Motion to withdraw attorney disposedGrant motion
09/20/2024Order entered 
09/18/2024Motion to withdraw attorney filed 
09/11/2024Appearance of counsel 
08/29/2024Order entered 
08/22/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
08/07/2024Reply brief filed 
07/09/2024Order entered 
07/09/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedGrant motion
07/02/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
06/20/2024Order entered 
06/20/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedGrant motion
06/18/2024Letter filed 
06/04/2024Response filed 
06/03/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
05/16/2024Case ready to be set 
05/16/2024Letter filed 
05/15/2024Amended brief filed 
05/15/2024Letter filed 
04/09/2024Order entered 
04/09/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
04/09/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
03/11/2024Order entered 
03/07/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
02/20/2024Motion to withdraw attorney filed 
02/12/2024Amended brief filed 
01/10/2024Order entered 
01/10/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
01/09/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
12/08/2023Order entered 
12/07/2023Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
11/13/2023Order entered 
10/13/2023Mandate issued 
09/01/2023Case remanded from higher court 
09/01/2023Opinion issuedOrder is VACATED
05/26/2023Letter filed 
04/20/2023Letter filed 
01/19/2023Letter filed 
07/05/2022Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedGrant motion
06/14/2022Letter received 
05/12/2022Letter filed 
04/05/2022Amicus curiae brief received 
09/29/2021Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
08/20/2021Motion for extension of time to file petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtGrant motion
08/19/2021Motion for extension of time to file petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
08/02/2021Letter filed 
07/14/2021Order entered 
07/14/2021Motion for en banc reconsideration disposedMotion or Writ Denied
06/23/2021Letter filed 
06/22/2021Letter filed 
06/10/2021Motion for en banc reconsideration filed 
06/01/2021Letter filed 
05/25/2021Order entered 
05/25/2021Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing disposedGrant motion
05/18/2021Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing enbanc filed 
05/11/2021Motion for rehearing disposedMotion or Writ Denied
05/11/2021Order entered 
05/04/2021Letter filed 
04/26/2021Motion for rehearing filed 
03/24/2021Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing disposedGrant motion
03/24/2021Order entered 
03/22/2021Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing filed 
03/10/2021Opinion issuedReversed and Rendered Pt/Reversed and Remanded Pt
01/19/2021Letter filed 
09/02/2020Submitted 
08/11/2020Set for submission on briefs - oral argument denied 
07/21/2020Mandate issued 
06/30/2020Reply brief filed 
06/11/2020Letter filed 
05/04/2020Brief filed - oral argument requested 
05/04/2020Case ready to be set 
05/04/2020Brief filed - oral argument not requested 
03/26/2020Order entered 
03/26/2020Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
03/24/2020Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
02/28/2020Order entered 
02/28/2020Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
02/26/2020Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
02/26/2020Motion to dismiss disposedMotion or Writ Granted
02/26/2020Memorandum opinion issuedDismissed in Part
02/03/2020Brief filed - oral argument requested 
02/03/2020Motion to dismiss filed 
01/23/2020Letter filed 
01/17/2020Supplemental clerks record filed 
01/15/2020Letter received 
01/15/2020Letter filed 
01/06/2020Order entered 
01/06/2020Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
12/30/2019Prescreened 
12/23/2019Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
12/20/2019Order entered 
12/04/2019Docketing statement due 
12/04/2019Order entered 
12/04/2019Extension of time to file clerks record disposedFiling is Noted by Court
12/03/2019Clerks record filed 
12/02/2019Extension of time to file clerks record filed 
11/06/2019Docketing statement filed 
11/06/2019Amended notice of appeal filed 
11/05/2019Notice of appeal filed in court of appeals 
11/04/2019Reporters record filed 
10/30/2019Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
10/29/2019Notice of appeal filed in court of appeals 
10/29/2019Case began in court of appeals 
10/09/2019Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
09/30/2019Judgment signed by trial court judge 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
10/09/2026Appeal to Higher CourtHigher court review
10/29/2019StatusPending action of court
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Colonial Villa Estates, LLCAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Eva M. Guzman
Paul F. Simpson
Joshua Smith
Ball, Linda M.AppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
Joshua Smith
Hoffman, Kent B.AppellantClinton Butler
Elizabeth Kopecki Marker  
Sylvia A. Cardona
CDG Peeler Family Limited PartnershipAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Joshua Smith
Whispering Pines Mobile Home Park, LtdAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Joshua Smith
Chen, Yu MinAppellantBryan Haynes
Christian Cowart
J. Liu Property, LLCAppellantBryan Haynes
Christian Cowart
Hoffman Binieck, Susan AppellantClinton Butler
Elizabeth Kopecki Marker  
Sylvia A. Cardona
Chi & Xiao Ltd.AppellantBryan Haynes
Christian Cowart
Shannon Family TrustAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Joshua Smith
Fleming, Patricia P.AppelleeJoshua Smith
Paul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Erzen, Jane ElizabethAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Joshua Smith
Paul F. Simpson
Coconut Point ST, LLCAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Joshua Smith
Paul F. Simpson
North Thomson Oil And Gas LPAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Joshua Smith
Christopher L. Halgren
The Graves Peeler HeirsAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
Joshua Smith
Collins, Sandra ShannonAppelleeJoshua Smith
Paul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Thomson, Gordon G.AppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Joshua Smith
Hoffman, Jr., E. PeterAppellantClinton Butler
Elizabeth Kopecki Marker  
Sylvia A. Cardona
He, DanAppellantBryan Haynes
Christian Cowart
Coconut Point OE, LLCAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
LFF Management L.P.AppellantChristian Cowart
Bryan Haynes
McCarty, Larry WayneAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Littlefield, Cynthia L.AppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Gu, TianpengAppellantChristian Cowart
Bryan Haynes
Chen, Ya MiinAppellantChristian Cowart
Bryan Haynes
Lazy Daze KLA, LLCAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
The Dick Family Irrevocable TrustAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
Pan, YujieAppellantBryan Haynes
Christian Cowart
Dick, Michael DavidAppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
Paul W. Peeler Family Limited PartnershipAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Thomson, Andrew M.AppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
Kong, XiangruiAppellantBryan Haynes
Christian Cowart
Cooney, Marni H.AppellantSylvia A. Cardona
Elizabeth Kopecki Marker  
Clinton Butler
R & H Paul, Inc.AppelleeChristopher L. Halgren
Paul F. Simpson
Thomson Oil & Gas Investments LPAppelleePaul F. Simpson
Christopher L. Halgren
Trial Court Information
36th Judicial District Court 
McMullen 
Honorable Janna K. Whatley 
M-17-0008-CV-C, Consolidated M-17-0034-CV-B 
Jennifer Hill